mesowatch
Oklahoma Appeals Court Holds Firm on $8 Million
Section divider

Oklahoma Appeals Court Holds Firm on $8 Million Mesothelioma Verdict

cuorthouse steps

In a legal showdown, an Oklahoma appeals court has affirmed an $8 million verdict in a tragic mesothelioma lawsuit. The case traces back five years, culminating in a decisive ruling that leaves defendants National Oilwell Varco LP, Union Carbide Corp., and Montello Inc. grappling with defeat.

Defending the Verdict

Despite relentless attempts by the defendants to cast blame elsewhere, the Oklahoma Court of Civil Appeals remains steadfast, refusing to overturn the trial court’s decision. Representing the estate of Brennan James Atkeson, Lisa Shirley of Dean Omar Branham Shirley lauded the verdict as a testament to exhaustive scrutiny of evidence and legal principles, offering a semblance of closure after years of legal tumult.

Unfolding Tragedy

The case’s roots delve back to 2016, when Atkeson initiated legal proceedings before his untimely passing, leaving his mother, Kim Fox-Jones, to carry the torch. Allegations surfaced of Atkeson’s exposure to asbestos fibers during his stepfather’s tenure at an oil drilling company from 1980 to 1985, ultimately leading to his fatal mesothelioma diagnosis. Despite fervent attempts at redirection, the jury’s resolute $8 million award in 2019 set the stage for a grueling appeals process.

Defendants spared no effort in contesting the verdict, citing prejudicial restrictions on evidence introduction implicating nonparties. However, the appeals court upheld the trial court’s decision, viewing it as a justifiable rebuke for the defendants’ opacity during discovery. In a captivating display of judicial scrutiny, Judge Thomas E. Prince cast light on the strategic underpinnings of the defendants’ maneuvers, underscoring the intricate dance of legal strategy in pursuit of justice.

Amid dissenting voices, the appeals panel remained steadfast in its support of the jury’s findings, emphasizing the paramount role of evidence presented by Fox-Jones. The court’s steadfast refusal to intercede in the jury’s determination underscores the primacy of factual evidence in establishing causation. As the legal tumult subsides, the ruling leaves an indelible mark on the legal landscape, reaffirming the judiciary’s authority to forestall attempts at scapegoating third parties.

The conclusion of this legal odyssey resonates far beyond the courtroom, imprinting itself on the legal consciousness. The ruling serves as a lodestar, illuminating crucial principles regarding causation, evidentiary standards, and judicial discretion. As the curtain falls on this gripping legal drama, the memory of Brennan James Atkeson lives on, his legacy forever intertwined with the pursuit of justice.

Matthew Davis

Reading Time: 1 mins

Published On: May 18, 2021

Matthew Davis - author

Matthew Davis is a freelance journalist who has covered civil litigation for a variety of publications. He joined Mesowatch in 2016 and covers asbestos litigation developments in the U.S., as well as newsworthy asbestos cases.

More to Read

Section Divider

John Edwards - September 24, 2024

Arizona Veterans: The Persistent Danger of Asbestos Exposure

Mini Divider

News & Data

News & Data Divider
Hands of a veteran in military uniform, clasped together in reflection.

Arizona Veterans: The Persistent Danger of Asbestos Exposure

By John Edwards

Read Story
j&j talcum powder bottle, contains asbestos

Johnson & Johnson Faces Critical Legal Test in Connecticut

By Matthew Davis

Read Story
chemotherapy is next frontier for mesothelioma treatment

FDA Approves Pembrolizumab with Chemotherapy for Advanced Mesothelioma

By Amna Anees

Read Story
https://www.istockphoto.com/photo/scales-of-justice-and-gavel-on-wooden-table-and-lawyer-or-judge-working-with-gm939262058-256820558

Asbestos Litigation Trends Reveal Ongoing Health Crisis, Study Finds

By Jared Reagan

Read Story
mesothelioma jury verdict

J&J Subsidiary Declares Bankruptcy to Push Forward $10 Billion Talc Settlement

By Rachel Sasser

Read Story
mark leniar trial lawyer secures 39m - lady justice texas flag

$39M Awarded In Mesothelioma Case Tied to Medical Contaminated Talc

By Rachel Sasser

Read Story
Featured Image

Is J&J Playing Fair? Lawyers Dispute the $1.1 Billion Talc Settlement Increase

By Matthew Davis

Read Story
Lady Justice And Columns Of A Courthouse Facade

J&J Raises Talcum Powder Settlement by Another $1.1 Billion

By Matthew Davis

Read Story
Mini Divider
mesowatch

Mesowatch serves as an industry watchdog and advocates for patients and families affected by asbestos by providing reliable and up-to-date news stories and information on asbestos and mesothelioma.

NAVIGATE

About UsEditorial GuidelinesNewsSupport and ResourcesPrivacy Policy

CONTACT US

Email: support@mesowatch.com

Phone: (866) 402-1000

Address: 3260 N Hayden Rd, Suite 210, Scottsdale, AZ 85251

Copyright © 2024 by Mesowatch. All Rights Reserved.
The content on this website is protected by law and provided for informational purposes only. It is not intended as a substitute for professional medical or legal advice. Always seek advice from qualified professionals for health or legal matters.Disclaimer