mesowatch
HomeSupreme Court Confirms $4M ExxonMobil Verdict
divider

Washington Supreme Court Confirms $4M ExxonMobil Asbestos Verdict

Steps leading to the Supreme Court building entrance at the capital of Washington

Washington’s highest court upheld a jury verdict against ExxonMobil Oil Co. that the company should be held accountable for exposing a contractor to asbestos that caused his mesothelioma and death. The jury originally found for $4 million in favor of the plaintiff, which was later reduced to $2.2 million after settlements with other defendants.

The Supreme Court’s ruling concluded that the trial judge acted in his judgment when he declined to give ExxonMobil a jury instruction on “known or obvious dangers.” The majority wrote that the record failed to show conclusively that the decedent, Warren Wright, fully knew about asbestos exposure despite taking some precautions.

According to ExxonMobil, the jury should have been told in the premises liability instruction if Wright was aware of the asbestos hazards. Yet justices discerned no legal need to combine these instructions and held that Wright’s measures of care were not a demonstration of knowledge of the severity of harm.

The case had already been upheld by a state appeals court in December 2021, which found the premises liability warning to have been properly delivered and that ExxonMobil had enough time to defend itself. But the appeals court had stayed the final judgment to review the fairness of the settlements with other defendants, not fully disclosed to ExxonMobil.

Dissenting Opinions on Risk Awareness

Dissenting Justice Barbara A Madsen said the jury ought to have been told about the known or obvious risks and that this absence did not help ExxonMobil advance its case that Wright had taken on the risks of his job. This dissent was also filed by Justice Gordon McCloud, who noted that Wright, an “attention to safety” type, ought to have been awarded the lesson given the precautions he used when working with asbestos.

Matthew Davis

Reading Time: 1 mins

Published On: July 30, 2023

Matthew Davis - author

Matthew Davis is a freelance journalist who has covered civil litigation for a variety of publications. He joined Mesowatch in 2016 and covers asbestos litigation developments in the U.S., as well as newsworthy asbestos cases.

More to Read

Section Divider

Amna Anees - November 17, 2024

CHMP Recommends Pembrolizumab and Chemo for Pleural Mesothelioma

Mini Divider
Mesowatch Logo

Mesowatch serves as an industry watchdog and advocates for patients and families affected by asbestos by providing reliable and up-to-date news stories and information on asbestos and mesothelioma.

NAVIGATE

About UsEditorial GuidelinesNewsSupport and ResourcesPrivacy PolicySitemap

CONTACT US

Email: support@mesowatch.com

Phone: (866) 402-1000

Address: 3260 N Hayden Rd, Suite 210, Scottsdale, AZ 85251

Copyright © 2024 by Mesowatch. All Rights Reserved.
At Mesowatch, we strive to provide helpful information for your journey. Please remember that the content on our website is for informational purposes only and is protected by copyright law. It is not a substitute for professional medical or legal advice. We encourage you to consult qualified professionals for any health or legal concerns. Disclaimer